Black students exceed state standards in math and science in 70 schools in LA County. Analysis finds higher proportion of Black teachers in “academic achievement outlier” schools
A new analysis by researchers at the UCLA Center for the Transformation of Schools identifies 70 “academic achievement outlier” (AAO) schools in Los Angeles County that consistently attain strong academic outcomes for Black Students. Black students at these AAO schools met or exceeded state standards in mathematics at rates 130 percent higher than their peers at non-AAO schools, and in English language arts at rates 74 percent higher. The study also finds that AAO schools had markedly stronger school climate indicators, with lower rates of chronic absenteeism and suspensions. The findings affirm the association between supportive school environments and strong academic outcomes.
“This study breaks new ground by conducting an analysis of publicly available California Department of Education data of Los Angeles County schools to identify where Black student achievement exceeds the level predicted by schoolwide economic disadvantage,” says Angela James, the lead author of the study and senior project scientist at the UCLA Center for the Transformation of Schools.
“In doing so, we aim to move beyond defining Black students by their deficits to instead illuminate their potential. It is critical that our methods of evaluation do not blind us to emerging solutions by fixating so exclusively on deficits that we cannot see emerging strengths, possibilities, and solutions.”
The study, “Freedom Dreaming and Academic Achievement: Outlier Schools Prioritizing Black Students in Los Angeles County,” develops a quantitative approach for systematically identifying schools in which Black students demonstrate academic outcomes that exceed statistical expectations. The aim of the project is to move beyond deficit-oriented study designs and research questions to instead uncover the characteristics of schools that consistently support academic success for Black students. The research intentionally seeks to identify schools in Los Angeles County that are consistently producing strong results in preparing Black students in both English language arts and mathematics.
“By deliberatively harnessing quantitative methods to identify strong and supportive schools, we seek to affirm that such schools exist in Los Angeles County and beyond and to highlight their efforts,” says Tyrone Howard, a professor of education at UCLA and a co-author of the report.
“The difference in mathematics outcomes in these schools is extraordinary and understanding what is happening to produce such outcomes is absolutely vital. Our intent is to shine a bright light on the conditions and strategies that further academic success for Black students and foster a greater understanding of how other schools can deliver equitable and high-quality education that prepares all students to thrive.”
In addition to identifying AAO schools where significant percentages of Black students exceed state goals for student achievement in English and Mathematics, key findings of the study include:
− Academic Achievement Outlier (AAO) schools have similar average total enrollment but serve higher average proportions of Black students than non-AAO schools. AAO schools have almost double the proportion of Black students compared to the countywide average.
− The average proportion of Black teachers at AAO schools is twice as high as the average proportion of Black teachers at non-AAO schools.
− Suspension rates are much lower at AAO schools compared to non-AAO schools. Black students in non-AAO schools are subjected to exclusionary discipline at more than triple the rate of AAO schools.
− The differences between AAO and non-AAO schools’ suspension rates at the middle and high school levels is dramatic. In comparison to AAO schools, overall suspension rates tend to be 3-4 times higher among non-AAO middle schools and 5-6 times higher in non-AAO high schools.
− Chronic absenteeism rates are substantially lower at AAO schools than at non-AAO schools. Chronic absenteeism rates at AAO schools are one-third less (35-38% less) than rates among non-AAO schools. Rates of chronic absenteeism specifically for Black students at AAO schools are significantly lower than for Black students at non-AAO schools.
− Average stability rates (the percentage of students enrolled at the school who completed a full year at that school) at AAO schools are higher than at other schools in the region, and even higher among Black students at AAO schools in comparison to non-AAO schools.
“Perhaps the most striking finding of this study is the differences in school climate,” said, Thomas Jacobson, an author of the report and research analyst at the Center for the Transformation of Schools. “AAO schools have higher overall levels of school stability, and lower levels of chronic absenteeism and suspension when compared to other schools. “In terms of school climate and student belonging, the disparities experienced by Black students are lesser.”
To address key issues identified in the research, the study’s authors offer specific recommendations. These include:
− Prioritize the recruitment of Black teachers
− Radically rethink school discipline
− Focus on building vibrant school culture
− Invest in Black students through targeted strategies with universal benefits
“The 70 schools identified in this study are indicative of the potential of public schools to prepare Black youth with the knowledge and skills necessary to excel in grades K-12 and beyond, said Joseph Bishop, a co-author of the report and the executive director of the Center for the Transformation of Schools.
“But this study is about more than identifying schools that outperform expectations. It is about expanding our collective imagination of what is possible for the education of Black students across Los Angeles County and beyond. Learning from these schools can provide an opportunity to learn from the practices and conditions that make educational success possible.
“In a sense, identifying and learning from Academic Outlier Schools is an act of freedom dreaming,” concludes James. “Rather than allowing persistent disparities to define what we believe Black students can achieve or what schools can become, we can use evidence of success to imagine different possibilities.”
The study, “Freedom Dreaming and Academic Achievement: Outlier Schools Prioritizing Black Students in Los Angeles County,“is a project of the Center for Transformation of Schools at the UCLA School of Education and Information Studies. The study is researched and authored by Angela James, Thomas Jacobson, Tyrone Howard and Joseph Bishop. Funding for the study was provided by the Ballmer Foundation. A second qualitative study will be published in 2027.